1984 is a book written by George Owel describing
the life of citizens in a country full of dictatorship, and also describing a
world where everything is completed differently. It is a pretty depressing book
in which we see a state controlling the language, controlling the thoughts, and
even controlling the reality that we live in. The system of the country described
is like a pyramid; at the top of the pyramid, there is BIG BROTHER the
dictator, and after there is the inner party that represent 2% of the society,
then we have the outer party where we find the ministry and where is Winston,
the main character of the 6th chapter of the book. In the bottom of
the pyramid, we find the paroles and they are the poorest of the society. The
most dangerous is the middle part.
Winston, the main character, is violating
multiple rules like keeping a diary is considered as a thought crime, or when
he fell in love and started an affair with a women named Julia, this was also a
crime, because, in this system, all you love should go to BIG BROTHER, the
dictator.
Now in this text, we could really notice how hard
it is to live in a country ruled by a dictator. As Tunisian and Libyans
students, we can really relate to this story given the fact that we lived in
countries ruled by dictators controlling our thoughts, our expressions, our
freedom, controlling what to say and what not to say. Before the revolution, we
really felt controlled, not directly, but it was impossible to be against the
system and have enough courage to speak about it loud and clear, because
everyone that did got himself into trouble and was promoting himself to torture
or even death.
With BIG BROTHER, it was different because they
controlled your thoughts and your beliefs, and if they tell you that 2+2=5, you
have to believe that even if it is not true. If you don’t believe that, you’ll
be tortured until you do believe what they are telling you, and they push to
the limit where you’ll betray the ones you love and the ones you cherish the
most by knowing all your weaknesses and the things that will hurt you the most,
making you feel like a robot and not having any reason to live for other than
BIG BROTHER. Winston was a victim of that kind of torture and he betrayed
Julia, his love, for this dictator.
We could never know what a person under torture
would react or what he would do to protect himself, because we did not get
ourselves in a situation where we had to be tortured. It is hard to feel what
others felt in some situations because they are so intense. Some people would
say that it was not good reason for Winston to betray his lover, because he
loved her and when we love someone and when we believe in something, we should
stick to it no matter what. But we could never know or feel what they felt in
that situation.
Torture is not the solution, and dictatorship
is done by people that are not confident about themselves, that are scared of
being alone and judged that they will make you love them, respect them and
change yourself for them so they can feel a little bit secure about themselves.
It is not and it will never be a solution for a country, it is mostly thought
of as the worst solution, because people eventually will turn on you, will realize
that it was never what they wanted, and that is not best for them nor for the
other generations coming.